• Top Story
  • Weekly
  • Latest
  • Editorial
  • Opinion
  • Interview
  • Feature
  • Sports
  • News
  • J&K
  • World
  • Education
  • Health
  • Economy
  • Culture
  • Literature
  • Lifestyle
  • Books
What's Hot

Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

January 8, 2025

Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

December 25, 2024

America’s Waning Global Position

November 4, 2024
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?
  • Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public
  • America’s Waning Global Position
  • Book Review—Shawls and Shawlbafs of Kashmir
  • Hundreds of Sheep Face Starvation as Forest Officials Bar Grazing
  • Photo Essay: Fire Fighting Service In Dal Lake
  • Pheran—How Kashmir’s Traditional Attire Evolved Through Centuries
  • Pheran—How Kashmir’s Traditional Attire Evolved Through Centuries
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
 Kashmir Newsline – Expression Unleashed Kashmir Newsline – Expression Unleashed
  • Weekly

    Weekly Dec 25 – Dec 31, 2022

    December 25, 2022

    Weekly Dec 05 – 11 Dec,2022

    December 7, 2022

    Weekly Nov 28 – Dec 04, 2022

    November 30, 2022

    Weekly November 21-27

    November 22, 2022

    Weekly November 14-20

    November 16, 2022
  • News
    1. India
    2. South Aisa
    3. World
    Featured
    Recent

    Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

    January 8, 2025

    Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

    December 25, 2024

    America’s Waning Global Position

    November 4, 2024
  • Feature
    1. Interview
    2. Literature
    3. Editorial
    4. Opinion
    5. Top Story
    6. Books
    7. View All

    Interview: ‘Travel, Observing and Tasting is the Best Way to Learn’

    October 2, 2023

    AS Dulat’s Kashmir Stories

    February 4, 2023

    Interview: ‘People are Deeply Pained by Mirwaiz’s Absence from Jamia Masjid’

    November 16, 2022

    ‘Abrogation of Article 370 has Made Kashmir More Dangerous than 1990s’

    October 18, 2022

    The Poet of Love—Daagh Dehlvi’s Poetry has Native Idiom and Sufi Undercurrent

    May 30, 2023

    The Breadth and Sweep of Sahir Ludhianvi’s Works

    March 8, 2023

    Memories of Gulmarg

    January 28, 2023

    ‘If This Language Lives On, Rahi Also Lives On’

    January 18, 2023

    Kashmir Needs Collective Fight against Glaring Drug Abuse

    December 27, 2022

    Healthcare Emergency

    December 7, 2022

    Traffic Mess: Who is to Blame? 

    November 30, 2022

    Give the Artists the Space They Need

    November 23, 2022

    Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

    January 8, 2025

    Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

    December 25, 2024

    America’s Waning Global Position

    November 4, 2024

    Writer’s Block What!

    October 8, 2023

    Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

    January 8, 2025

    Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

    December 25, 2024

    America’s Waning Global Position

    November 4, 2024

    Book Review—Shawls and Shawlbafs of Kashmir

    September 12, 2024

    Book Review—Shawls and Shawlbafs of Kashmir

    September 12, 2024

    Book Review: The Divine Dialect of Flowers

    October 5, 2023

    The Collision That Birthed Religion

    March 18, 2023

    Book Review: What is the Meter of the Dictionary?

    March 2, 2023

    Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

    January 8, 2025

    Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

    December 25, 2024

    America’s Waning Global Position

    November 4, 2024

    Book Review—Shawls and Shawlbafs of Kashmir

    September 12, 2024
  • J&K

    Hundreds of Sheep Face Starvation as Forest Officials Bar Grazing

    March 14, 2024

    Photo Essay: Fire Fighting Service In Dal Lake

    March 8, 2024

    Tatakooti—Challenges of Owning a Towering Peak

    October 5, 2023

    Interview: ‘Travel, Observing and Tasting is the Best Way to Learn’

    October 2, 2023

    What is Ailing the Apple Farming?

    September 16, 2023
  • Lifestyle

    Eating Together Binds Families

    November 22, 2022

    How Smartphones are Harming Children

    October 25, 2022

    Raising a Champion

    October 11, 2022

    The Reluctant ‘Urban Poor’

    August 28, 2022

    The Reluctant ‘Urban Poor’

    August 21, 2022
  • Economy

    Explained: What is a Credit Score and Why is it Important?

    December 27, 2022

    Rights of Special Bank Customers

    November 30, 2022

    How to be a Socially Responsible Investor

    November 23, 2022

    Stock Exchange Crimes

    November 16, 2022

    Avoid Debt Trap

    November 8, 2022
  • Culture
  • Entertainment
  • Sports

    Tatakooti—Challenges of Owning a Towering Peak

    October 5, 2023

    When Salim was in the Mood

    July 12, 2023

    Why Does Team India Fail Consistently?

    December 27, 2022

    Hail Ben Stokes and Co.

    December 7, 2022

    England Tour of Pakistan

    November 30, 2022
 Kashmir Newsline – Expression Unleashed Kashmir Newsline – Expression Unleashed
Home»J&K»Why the Return of the KPs to the Valley is Farfetched
J&K

Why the Return of the KPs to the Valley is Farfetched

Kashmir NewslineBy Kashmir NewslineJuly 6, 2022Updated:July 10, 2022No Comments14 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

More than three decades after their exodus, the return of Kashmiri Pandits (KPs) remains a mirage for a host of reasons including the weaponization of the KP misery by the rightwing to further its communal agenda.

Amit Bamzai

A somber-looking septuagenarian Muslim neighbour looking mindlessly into nothingness surrounding him, with a pair of pink sandals resting next to him. These sandals are all that was found next to the body of Rajni Bala when she was murdered near Govt. High School, Gopalpara in South Kashmir’s Kulgam district. Bala hailed from Jammu’s Samba district and was posted as a teacher in Kulgam.

Over the last five to six weeks, gunmen executed more than five individuals across the length and breadth of Kashmir which included Revenue official Rahul Bhat, artist Ambreen Bhat, Police official Saifullah Qadri and EDB manager Vijay Kumar.

These recent killings of selected individuals have caused a sense of fear among individuals from the minority community working in the Valley. The sheer audacity and strategic execution of these targets has indicated sleeper cells, possibly run by Pakistani handlers. This is what former R&AW (Research and Analysis wing) Chief and New Delhi’s premier pointsman on Kashmir during Vajpayee regime, AS Dulat, made of the grisly events.

In an interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Dulat said that the planning and the precise execution of these murders not only has a Pakistani connection but could also be supported by a deeply entrenched network of OGWs (overground workers). He further implies that a largely silent rage over the dilution of the special status provided to the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir could also be a cause for this growing sentiment of antipathy towards the minorities in Kashmir.

Demographic change: genuine threat or a bogeyman?

The removal of article 370 has fanned the apprehension of a systematic demographic change in Kashmir.

The calls to resist attempts at demographic alteration have arisen intermittently in Kashmir in the last three decades. These concerns are further accentuated by loud demands from mainland India in favour of the settlement of non-Muslims from various parts of India in Kashmir via different policies, assuming it would scotch the anti-India sentiment in Kashmir or at least render the secessionist lobby a minority. Such extreme demands have also come from senior politicians like Subramaniam Swamy, who suggested in a conference hosted by Panun Kashmir – a rightwing Pandit organisation that claims to espouse the cause of KP’s – that retired soldiers, and police personnel can be settled in Kashmir as a policy to challenge the secessionist supremacy. Needless to say, such comments have alarmed Kashmiri Muslims. More than a decade ago, I spoke with a staunch Hurriyat supporter who told me that there will be many policies leading to settlements of non-Muslims in Kashmir. His apprehensions were echoed by noted political scientist and bitter critic of the Hindu right Pratap Bhanu Mehta when he wrote:  “Political violence in India is intimately tied to a demographic imagination […] In Kashmir, the fear of altering demography after the abrogation of Article 370 has been palpably real”

It is imperative to note that the presence of the Union gov’t of India’s personnel in Kashmir is temporary in nature and doesn’t alter the results of elections in any form. However, several instances of malfunctioning in elections have rendered their outcomes meaningless in the eyes of the Kashmiris who believe that the chief ministers in J&K aren’t elected in Srinagar but rather selected in New Delhi.

Former JKLF Chief Yasin Malik who has recently been convicted in a money laundering case and Late SAS Geelani termed the appointment of Kashmiri Pandit employees in Kashmir via Prime Minister’s relief package as a precursor to demographic alteration in Kashmir. It led to a gradual building of a sense of fear and resentment among Kashmiri Muslims. PM package employees who had already accepted their jobs, that came with certain caveats, with a lot of trepidation. One of the conditions being that the beneficiaries can’t seek transfer once they’re posted in Kashmir. In the wake of recent killings of Pandits and a couple of Hindus from Jammu who were posted in Kashmir, these caveats have become the biggest hurdle in instilling a sense of security amongst the Pandit employees who have been asking to be transferred to safer areas in Jammu and other districts. Although the presence of a couple of thousand Hindu employees may pose very little or no immediate threat to the Muslim majority in Kashmir, blatant calls of Muslim genocide and other forms of violence coming from Hindutva echo-chambers doesn’t help in assuaging such fears.

Under such circumstances, statements of Yasin Malik and Late Geelani only add fuel to the fire. Add to that Pakistan vehemently bringing up the issue on multiple forums and the demography fears only grow stronger.

 

Did the separatist leadership have a role in maintaining peace and security?

On August 5, 2019 Immediately after placing the Presidential Order 2019 before the Rajya Sabha, Home Minister Amit Shah moved a resolution recommending that the president issue an order under Article 370(3) rendering all clauses of Article 370 inoperative. It further led to the dissolution of the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir out of which two Union territories of Jammu and Kashmir and UT of Ladakh were carved. Some of my friends who worked for the mainstream parties in the state felt their party leadership was undermined. They were expecting a deluge of protest against the resolution. None of that happened. Home Minster Amit Shah, in one stroke, rendered a host of pro-India Leaders redundant in Kashmir. What was feared for a while by political analysts came out to be true. Kashmiris had little faith in the claims made by the likes of NC and PDP about the intent of the rule of Indian democracy in the Valley.

In a way the removal of article 370 was a vindication of the stand that Hurriyat and other separatist groups maintained, For decades they have espoused that there is no real democracy on the ground in Kashmir.  Yasin Malik, former chief of JKLF and a self-proclaimed Gandhian has for long remained a known face of the separatist movement in Kashmir. Almost all previous gov’ts from Narsimha Rao to Manmohan Singh have flirted with the idea of bringing Malik and other separatist leaders to the so-called mainstream politics in Kashmir. However, Malik, Geelani et al maintained that the resolution of the conflict in J&K can’t be found within the confines of the Indian constitution.

While most of the militants who picked up arms during the fag end of the 80’s or during the beginning of 90’s were eliminated; Yasin Malik not only survived but became a larger than life Kashmiri figure around the well with his newly acquired Gandhian credentials doing his image a world of good and giving him a huge platform in the national and international media. Malik was even a member of a panel that met the former Prime minister Dr. Manmohan Singh. The photographs of Yasin shaking hands with Dr. Singh keep haunting the Congress party till today with its nemesis, the BJP, making most of such images.

In May this year, NIA court handed Malik a lifer for receiving funds to spark unrest in the valley. In its charge sheet, the NIA claimed that Malik received money through a Pakistani diplomat posted in New Delhi.

While Malikhas always maintained a public stance of welcoming Kashmiri Pandits back to the valley, he bitterly opposed the govt. of India’s idea to settle them in guarded settler colonies.

Yasin Malik and other separatists were considered valuable allies to control and also sometimes divert the sentiment on the streets of Srinagar by the Indian state. However, during Modi’s second term as prime minister powered by a thumping win in the 2019 polls, Yasin and other separatist leaders were rendered useless on that count. In fact, making a total departure from New Delhi’s earlier policies on Kashmir, the Centre went hammer and tongs after the separatist through investigative and law enforcement agencies.

Most of the Kashmiris I talked to while writing this essay referred to the absence of this force as a major reason for the recent upheaval in the Vale.

 

Why is the PM’s employment package suffocating Pandits?

During the reign of UPA govt. in 2008, PM Manmohan Singh announced an employment package for educated and yet unemployed Pandit youth. It led to the appointment of several thousand Kashmiri Pandits who were bound to serve in various districts of the Kashmir valley. This number has now risen to 4500. This employment package was a part of the relief and rehabilitation program launched by the govt. of India to resettle Kashmiri Pandits back in the Valley who had left during the eruption of militancy in Kashmir.

This employment package has however become a cause of massive unrest in the wake of the recent targeted killing of Hindu minorities in the Kashmir valley. According to the binding rules of this employment package, employees can only be posted in their home districts and are ineligible for transfers to any other place. In the wake of resigning from these jobs, Pandit employees become ineligible for any other gov’t jobs in Jammu and Kashmir. Due to such precondition, late Rahul Bhat was posted in Tehsil office of the village Chadoora in Budgam district. It was during the office hours when he was gunned down inside his office. Later, speaking to media personnel, his wife claimed that Rahul was feeling insecure in this remote location and had repeatedly asked the local administration to transfer him to safer district headquarters.

The brutal killing of Rahul caused the PM package employees to resign en mass and according to various news reports around 350 Pandit employees submitted their resignations to LG Manoj Sinha. The nature of the murder of Rahul Bhat had indicated the involvement of local Kashmiri employees in his office. A concern shared by Dulat in his interview with Thapar.

 

Kashmir Files

On 11th March 2022, The Kashmir files, a Hindi film was released across cinema halls in India. It is a fictional account based on the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits from the valley in 1990. The critical reception of the film was mixed, with the cinematography and acting thought to be compelling, but the storyline attracting criticism for attempting to recast established history and propagating Islamophobia. Supporters have praised the film for showing what they say is an overlooked aspect of Kashmir’s history.

This film received unprecedented support from the Modi govt. with a special mention by the prime minister himself. However; the former chief minister of the state Farooq Abdullah had very critical view of the film and the intent of its makers. He called the film an attempt to malign the Kashmiri Muslims and create a divide in the country due to several scenes depicting gory details of the murder of Pandits in Kashmir. He made a special mention of the scene in which a Pandit is killed and rice soaked in his blood is fed to his surviving wife. He referred to it as an outright lie and said it is not possible that a Muslim would do this to his Pandit brother in Kashmir. Farooq’s utterances notwithstanding, it was widely reported that B.K Ganjoo a former employee of the BSNL was killed in the same fashion, and his unfortunate wife was made to undergo this inhuman act. This story was, however, refuted by his surviving brother, SK Ganjoo.

Irrespective of its merit, it is widely being felt that Kashmir Files is being weaponized by the right-wing in India to propagate their prejudice and hatred towards minorities. The deeply dividing discourse around the film and the capitalizing on the trauma of Pandits to score political goals has become a worrying reality. People chanting anti-Muslim slogans inside and outside theatres and calling for revenge after watching the movie went viral on social media.

Although to claim that the murder of Rahul Bhat and later Rajni Bala was triggered by the aroused sentiment due to the film is downright wrong and preposterous. Individuals from the minorities were being targeted and killed in a planned manner for more than two years before the film was released. The murder of M.L Bindroo and later of Sikh school Principal Supinder Kour were incidents that happened before the release of the movie.

In both the cases a little-known militant  group took responsibility, accusing both the victims of promoting Indian agenda in Kashmir and propagating anti-Islamic activities.  It would be intellectual dishonesty to disregard the void that is being created between the two prominent communities in Kashmir. Especially with the nature of the recent killings, the involvement of ordinary Kashmiris in executing these target killings has created a blinding fear amongst the minuscule minority in Kashmir reminding them of the troubled times of 90 and 91. This gash that has opened now will take a herculean effort to be sewed again.

 

Hindutva and its Impact

For decades now, the KP issue has become a favourite horse to be flogged in India for the right wing. The ascent of militant right in India has coincided with coming to power for the nationalist, right wing politics in major countries like Turkey, Britain, Brazil etc.

However, in case of Indian politics, the curious case of KPs and reminder of their suffering became an excellent electoral plank to garner majoritarian sentiments. I have witnessed numerous occasions when in the coastal areas of Maharashtra, Delhi, Rajasthan the non-Muslim community has been reminded of what happened to Pandits.

It is no secret that, for years, J&K has remained a lab for Hindutva and nationalist politics where experiments are conducted to be used across rest of the country. Unfortunately, the brunt of its adverse effect has been borne by Pandits in the Valley as well where they had to face resistance and reprisal. Pandits have in the past been chided sometimes as ‘Jan Sanghis’,  an allusion to the parent organisation of BJP, the Jan Sangh. They have been known to be loyal voters of BJP and, therefore, instant targets for the separatist lobby. As the direct control of BJP rule gets stronger in the valley; Pandit organizations like Panun Kashmir have urged the Indian state to carry out the necessary purge in the valley to make it more Indian. It is a fallacious claim that Kashmiri  Pandits are en masse a BJP vote bank or out and out Hindutava supporters. One of the reasons, perhaps, why the KP’s continue to suffer is that they are a miniscule minority and have a negligible bearing on the electoral politics. That they have been so central to the majoritarian politics underscores the genius and focus of the Hindu right to use them as an electoral weapon not only to make electoral gains but also to keep live their divisive politics of keeping aloof and otherising the Muslims or any other idea that challenges their idea of India which is Akhand Bharat or the Greater India which, in the imagination of the Hindutva followers, is expansion of India beyond its borders, going as far off as Afghanistan, borne of myths and alternate history that the Sangh Parivar peddles with total disregard for historical data or the thumb rules that the historians are supposed to go by.

Like many other ethnic groups, Kashmiri Pandits too belong to a scattered political spectrum rather than a monolith. It is in place to mention that during the Sheikh Abdullah agitation, and even afterwards, most of the communist leaders in Kashmir were Pandits. Even some of them like late Raghunath Vaishnavi and Sampat Prakash wrote liberally about their sympathies for this protracted struggle for a separate state in Kashmir.

As the valley inches towards an eerie peace and the Pandit employees are being moved to high-security offices while their families remain virtually locked inside govt. enclosures like in Haal, Pulwama, their safety remains precariously edged on a precipice. It is now to be seen if the gov’t, powers that be and the Kashmiri society, in general, will stand up and help each other to move out of these murky waters.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Kashmir Newsline
  • Website

Related Posts

Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

January 8, 2025

Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

December 25, 2024

America’s Waning Global Position

November 4, 2024

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Top Posts

Team India’s Next Big Thing

July 6, 202227,463 Views

Why This Alpine Lake Trek Stands Out

July 6, 202225,423 Views

India’s Majoritarian Politics and the Role of Media

July 6, 202224,120 Views

Fragile Media Economies and Lack of Opportunities in Kashmir

July 6, 202223,225 Views
Don't Miss
Top Story

Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

By Kashmir NewslineJanuary 8, 20250

BRI’s transformative potential extends beyond economic development. It has the power to reshape global trade…

Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

December 25, 2024

America’s Waning Global Position

November 4, 2024

Book Review—Shawls and Shawlbafs of Kashmir

September 12, 2024
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Vimeo

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from SmartMag about art & design.

Based out of Srinagar (Jammu & Kashmir) and brought out in print as a weekly with online presence as well, Kashmir Newsline is solely committed to ethical, fearless journalism. We at Kashmir Newsline cover politics, geopolitics, international relations, social issues, health, sports and almost everything else as objectively as humanly possible. Kashmir Newsline carries detailed reports and in-depth analysis on multiple developments happening in Kashmir and around the world.

Facebook X (Twitter)
Our Picks

Belt and Road Initiative: How Real is ‘Debt-trap Diplomacy’?

January 8, 2025

Why Pegasus Report Must be Made Public

December 25, 2024

America’s Waning Global Position

November 4, 2024
Most Popular

Team India’s Next Big Thing

July 6, 202227,463 Views

Why This Alpine Lake Trek Stands Out

July 6, 202225,423 Views

India’s Majoritarian Politics and the Role of Media

July 6, 202224,120 Views
Facebook X (Twitter)
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Politics
  • J&K
  • E-Paper
  • Contact Us
© 2025 Kashmir Newsline. Designed by NexG IT Solutions.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Go to mobile version